2004

First Round
Chicago 67, St. Mary’s (Minn.) 50
UW-Stevens Point 65, Southwestern 42

Consolation
Southwestern 72, St. Mary’s (Minn.) 61

Championship
UW-Stevens Point 70, Chicago 58

2003

First Round
Illinois Wesleyan 73, Chicago 48
Trinity (Texas) 75, Springfield 68

Consolation
Chicago 78, Springfield 66

Championship
Trinity (Texas) 67, Ill. Wesleyan 65

2002

First Round
Chicago 93, Kenyon 58
Thiel 71, St. John’s (Minn.) 67

Consolation
St. John’s (Minn.) 72, Kenyon 68

Championship
Chicago 84, Thiel 68

2001

First Round
Beloit 80, Chicago 70 (ot)
Ohio Northern 76, Ohio Wesleyan 58

Consolation
Chicago 77, Ohio Wesleyan 70

Championship
Ohio Northern 68, Beloit 56

2000

First Round
Chicago 76, Colorado College 47
DePauw 80, Bowdoin 65

Consolation
Bowdoin 78, Colorado College 66

Championship
Chicago 84, DePauw 81

1999

First Round
Chicago 75, Earlham 54
Rose-Hulman 66, Illinois Tech 56

Consolation
Illinois Tech 67, Earlham 59

Championship
Chicago 56, Rose-Hulman 49

1998

First Round
Chicago 79, Kenyon 63
North Park 89, Aurora 76

Consolation
Aurora 101, Kenyon 97

Championship
Chicago 67, North Park 64

1997

First Round
Chicago 81, Adrian 61
UW-River Falls 64, Savannah A&D 50

Consolation
Savannah A&D 59, Adrian 58

Championship
UW-River Falls 65, Chicago 58

Points
40
Derek Reich, Chicago
vs. Thiel (11/24/02)

Rebounds
15
Craig Kelleher, Chicago
vs. North Park (11/22/98)

Field Goals Made
13
Derek Reich, Chicago
vs. Thiel (11/24/02)

3-Point Field Goals Made
7
Chad Plotke, Kenyon
vs. Aurora (11/22/98)

Free Throws Made
12
Jon Poyer, Chicago
vs. Ohio Wesleyan (11/18/01)

Assists
11
Shaka Smart, Kenyon
vs. Aurora (11/22/98)

Blocked Shots
6
Sean Devins, Trinity (Texas)
vs. Illinois Wesleyan (11/23/03)

Steals
5
Jason Couisnard, Adrian
vs. Savannah (11/23/97)

Pat McKenzie, St. John’s (Minn.)
vs. Thiel (11/23/02)

40
Derek Reich, Chicago
vs. Thiel (11/24/02)

28
Jabari Harrell, Aurora
vs. North Park (11/21/98)

Jason Kalsow, UW-Stevens Point
vs. Chicago (11/21/04)

Jon Poyer, Chicago
vs. Ohio Wesleyan (11/18/01)

27
David Baranowski, Bowdoin
vs. Colo. College (11/19/00)

Jim Conrad, Ohio Northern
vs. Ohio Wesleyan (11/17/01)

26
Kevin Buth, St. John’s (Minn.)
vs. Kenyon (11/24/02)

Shawn Kindred, Ohio Wesleyan
vs. Chicago (11/18/01)

Derek Reich, Chicago
vs. DePauw (11/19/00)

25
Keelan Amelianovich, Illinois Wesleyan
vs. Chicago (11/22/03)

Nick Bennet, UW-Stevens Point
vs. Chicago (11/21/04)

Aaron Bowser, Southwestern
vs. St. Mary’s (Minn.) (11/21/04)

Jim Conrad, Ohio Northern
vs. Beloit (11/18/01)

A.H. Davis, Thiel
vs. Chicago (11/24/02)

David Houston, Kenyon
vs. Aurora (11/22/98)

Mike Howland, DePauw
vs. Chicago (11/19/00)

Nebojsa Kesic, Kenyon
vs. Aurora (11/22/98)

Steve Mori, Illinois Tech
vs. Earlham (11/21/99)

Chad Plotke, Kenyon
vs. Aurora (11/22/98)

24
Dan DeBruycker, Aurora vs. Kenyon (11/22/98)
Derek Reich, Chicago vs. Beloit (11/17/01)

23
Mike Banach, Thiel vs. St. John’s (Minn.) (11/23/02)

22
Adam Dauksas, Illinois Wesleyan
vs. Trinity (Texas) (11/23/03)

Chad Meschke, UW-River Falls
vs. Savannah (11/22/97)

Tyler Smithson, Chicago
vs. Ohio Wesleyan (11/18/01)

Joe Ringger, DePauw
vs. Bowdoin (11/18/00)